Ansche Chesed
December 2003 Newsletter
)
 251 W.100 Street, NY, NY 10025 212-865-0600              www.AnscheChesed.org 
In this issue
  • December Calendar
  • Family Programs
  • Classes & Events
  • Study Groups
  • Shabbat Learning & Events
  • Services
  • New Executive Director
  • Donations
  • Musical Director Letter

  • Greetings!

    November was another busy month that included the hiring of our new Executive Director, Randi Jaffe. Randi's official start date was December 1st. Learn more about Randi and her great experience in the "New Executive Director" section below.

    In November we also held community discussions about hiring a Musical Director. See Rabbi Kalmanofsky's letter on this subject in the "Musical Director Letter" section below.

    Our main activity for December is the 23rd annual Hanukkah Arts Festival & Judaica Crafts Fair on December 6th and 7th. The Saturday night gala includes Mike Cohen's Klezmer band, delicious desserts and lots of crafts. Plus a Scotch, Wine, Champagne as well as Fancy Tea Tasting. Sunday includes fun events for kids. See more details in the "Classes and Events" section below.

    Check out the other events planned for Hanukkah, the 12/16 cooking event with Levana Kirschenbaum, the Dinner & A Movie night for Teens 12/2, the Young Judaea programs for 3-5th graders, the upcoming classes starting in January, and save January 24th for a special tribute to Ellen Braitman, Sylvia Ettenberg, Ellen Tucker & Alan Rosenstein.

    December Calendar

    WEEK OF DECEMBER 1ST
    12/1 Learn to Read Hebrew 7:15 PM
    12/2 Young Judaea Youth Group 5:45-7PM
    12/2 Dinner & A Movie for Teens 5:45PM
    12/3 Lunchtime Learning w/ R. Kalmanofsky 12PM
    12/3 Hevra Shas w/ R. Kalmanofsky 6:30PM
    12/3 Yiddish Group 7:30PM
    12/5 Candle Lighting 4:11PM, Services 5:30PM
    12/6 Torah Study 9AM
    12/6 Shabbat Services 10AM
    12/6 HANUKKAH ARTS FESTIVAL 8-11PM
     

    WEEK OF DECEMBER 7th
    12/7 HANUKKAH ARTS FESTIVAL 11AM - 5PM
    12/8 Hevrat Sarah 7:45PM
    12/8 Start of "Room to Grow" clothing/toy/book drive
    12/9 Israel Fiction in Translation
    12/9 Zionist Reading Group 7:30PM
    12/10 Lunchtime Learning w/ R. Kalmanofsky 12PM
    12/10 Hevra Shas w/ R. Kalmanofsky 6:30PM
    12/10 Yiddish Group 7:30PM
    12/12 Candle Lighting 4:11PM, Services 5:30PM
    12/13 Torah Study 9AM
    12/13 Shabbat Services 10AM
    12/13 Family Kiddush after Childrens' Services
    12/13 Jacob Stuchiner havdalah bar mitzvah
    12/14 Hanukkah Workshop for ages 2-5, 10:30AM- Noon
    12/14 Young Judaea Youth Group 4-6PM
    12/16 In the Kitchen w/ Levana Kirschenbaum

    WEEK OF DECEMBER 14th
    12/15 Board of Trustees meeting 8PM
    12/17 Lunchtime Learning w/ R. Kalmanofsky 12PM
    12/17 Hevra Shas w/ R. Kalmanofsky 6:30PM
    12/17 Yiddish Group 7:30PM
    12/19 Candle Lighting 4:13PM, Services 5:30PM
    12/20 Matthew Goldenberg bar mitzvah
    12/20 Torah Study 9AM
    12/20 Shabbat Services 10AM
    12/20 Seudah Shlishit 3:45PM
    12/20 Family Hannukah Party
    12/20 Last day of "Room to Grow" Drive

    WEEK OF DECEMBER 21st and 28th
    12/25 Office Closed
    12/26 Candle Lighting 4:16PM, Services 5:30PM
    12/27 Torah Study 9AM
    12/27 Shabbat Services 10AM-no Learners minyan
     

    JANUARY
    1/6 8PM "The Mitzvah of Feeding Others" class starts
    1/8 7:30 PM "Uneasy Abundance: Food & American Jewish Culture" class starts
    1/24 A tribute to Ellen Braitman, Sylvia Ettenberg, Ellen Tucker & Alan Rosenstein
    1/30 Jewish Life on the Rise in Germany speaker

    Family Programs

    Children's Shabbat services
    Preschool Service, llana Garber / Shai Specht
    For families with children ages 4 and under
    11:00 a.m. - Noon. 2 South.
    Family Service, Elena Sassower
    For children ages 5-7 and their parents.
    10:45-12:15pm. 6th West.
    Family Davening, Mindy Fischer / Tommy Treitel
    For children 8+ and up and their parents. 11:00-12:15pm. 6 North.
     

    Family Kiddush Together
    December 13th after Children's Services- in 6W
    Families with children are invited for an extended Kiddush. This is a great time to snack, shmooze and get to know other AC families.

    Young Judaea Youth Group - Grades 3- 5
    Tuesday, December 2 from 5:45-7 pm
    Sunday, December 14 from 4-6 pm

    3rd-5th graders are invited to join the Young Judaea youth group at Ansche Chesed. See old friends, make new ones, have fun and eat pizza! The club meets at AC twice monthly. For more information or to RSVP to an upcoming meeting, please contact Noah Wilker, Group Leader 212-451-6878 or nwilker@youngjudaea.org
     

    Dinner and a Movie for Teens
    Tuesday, December 2nd at 5:45 p.m.
    We will be meeting on the 5th floor. Feel free to bring friends! RSVP to Lauren.Kurland@anschechesed.org.
     

    Second Annual Room to Grow Drive
    December 8-December 20
    Join Ansche Chesed, our Hebrew School, Morningside Montessori, Discovery Programs, Purple Circle, and Yaldaynu in a drive to benefit Room To Grow. Room To Grow is a non-profit organization that helps NYC children born into poverty during their critical first three years of life. Parents visit Room To Grow every three months to receive clothing, books and toys for their growing baby, free of charge. Along with your donated items, Room To Grow parents receive developmental information and guidance. Please bring new or nearly new children's clothing and toys for children under age 3 to the Ansche Chesed lobby.

    Hanukkah Workshop for Families with Kids 2- 5
    Sunday, December 14, 10:30 - Noon
    Yaldaynu and the Ansche Chesed Family Education Department invite families with children ages 2-5 to attend a Family Hanukkah Workshop. We will make our own presents, decorate Hanukkah cookies, sing Hanukkah songs and learn more about the Festival of Lights. Cost: $10 for first child; $5 for each additional child. RSVP to Elaine Bloom at 212-866-4993 or yaldaynu@aol.com.
     

    Family Hanukkah Party
    Saturday night, December 20th
    Celebrate the second night of Hanukkah at a special Havdallah for families. Bring your Hanukkah candles and menorahs, and get ready for latkes,sufganiyot (jelly doughnuts), songs and fun!

    Family Shabbat Gym and Basketball
    Shabbat Gym, the best deal on indoor play space around, allows families to meet, schmooze, and enjoy each others' company on those chilly Shabbat afternoons from now until March.
    From 3:00 to 5:00 p.m., for children ages 1-7, we offer free play.
    Season fee per family: Members $40, Non-members $75.
    From 5:00 to 6:00 p.m., the gym is open for children ages 8 and older to play basketball.
    Season fee per family: Members $20, non-members $40.
    Application forms are available at the office, or online at www.anschechesed.org/education/family/shabbatgym20 03.htm, or call the AC office at ext. 412 for more information.

    Check out the Family Education section of the AC website »

    Classes & Events
    23rd Annual Hanukkah Arts Festival
    Saturday night Dec. 6th and Sunday Dec. 7th
    Admission: Sat. night Gala: $20; Sunday: $6 Adults, $5 Children

    NYC's longest-running Judaica crafts fair is a marvelous marketplace of exciting, creative and affordable Jewish crafts, as well as Jewish books, music, toys, and more!

    The Saturday night event includes wonderful desserts and drinks, along with a great live Klezmer band, Scotch,Wine, Champagne and Fancy Tea tastings. The all-day Sunday extravaganza includes the Maccabee Cafe and fun activities for kids. Plus, we're holding a 50/50 raffle - a way to win some serious gelt.

    Support artists from Israel and the US. Stock up on gifts and treat yourself to items that will make your home and life more beautiful and meaningful. The fair supports Ansche Chesed, and you'll have a great time.

    We also need sponsors: $150 donation (tax deductible!) includes 2 tickets to the Saturday night gala and a listing in the program. And, we need volunteers to help staff the festival. Please call the office at 212-865-0600 and leave a message for Jane Head or Mary Feinberg.

    An Evening in the Kitchen with Levana Kirschenbaum
    Tuesday, December 16 at 7:30PM
    Spend an evening with Levana Kirschenbaum of the famous "Levana" restaurant, and learn how to make some of her favorite recipes from her own kitchen. Levana's cooking reflects her Moroccan background as well as Meditteranean, Italian, Indian, vegetarian, and Chinese influences and has won her fans around the globe. Levana will also sign her book, "Levana's Table: Kosher Cooking for Everyone". Suggested donation $5. Please RSVP to the office at ext. 415

    Lunchtime Learning with Rabbi Jeremy Kalmanofsky
    Wednesdays, Noon-1:00 PM (not meeting on 12/24 or 31) No fee.
    Many of the Bible's greatest stories in terms of literary artistry, spiritual depth and national significance are not found in the Torah at all, but in the less often studied books of Judges, Samuel, and Kings. Join Rabbi Kalmanofsky to study these masterpieces in English (while also consulting Hebrew). Bring lunch if you'd like, and join us every week you can.

    Hevra Shas with Rabbi Jeremy Kalmanofsky
    Wednesdays, 6:30 PM (not meeting on 12/24 or 31) No fee.
    We continue our "weekly page" study of Babylonian Talmud, tractate Avoda Zara (Idolatry), examining important questions of how Jews interact with the non- Jewish world outside their own community. Most members of this class use the ArtScroll English-Hebrew Talmud (volume one of this tractate), enabling them both to read the traditional text and fully understand the content.

    New classes coming in January
    "Corners of the Field: The Mitzvot of Feeding Others" with Rabbi David Rosenn
    4 Tuesdays, 8:00-9:30 PM
    January 6, 13, 20, 27
    AC members $50, non-members $65

    We will look at the ways Jewish teachings apply to the task of combating hunger in New York City, in Israel, and around the world and develop ideas for individual and communal action.

    "Uneasy Abundance: Food and American Jewish Culture" with Eve Jochnowitz
    4 Mondays, 7:30-9:00 PM
    January 8, 15, 22, 29
    AC members $50, non-members $65

    This course offers an introduction to historic, religious, and ethnographic approaches to the study of food in American Jewish life. We will examine the culinary strategies of Jews in the reshaping of the American gastronomic landscape; in Jewish media; in creating Jewish cookbooks; and in the gender roles of the Old World and New.

    Study Groups
    Hevrat Sarah
    December 8 at 7:45PM

    Israel Reading Group
    December 9 at 7:30 PM
    We invite you to join a group of people who want to read Israeli fiction together at Ansche Chesed. We want to see more clearly the cultural issues alive now in Israel by reading its fiction. We will meet one Tuesday evening a month. I've proposed that we begin with a collection of novellas, edited by Gershon Shaked, called Six Israeli Novellas. It covers fiction of the 1960s, '70s and '80s. The book is available from Amazon.com. It will prepare us for fiction of the '90s and beyond. We would like this to be a participant-led group. Let's read the first story in the collection for the first meeting: Ruth Almog's "Shrinking." If you would like to join us, please email me atjburstei@drew.edu or call at 212 316 1386. -- Janet Burstein.

    Yiddish for the 21st Century with Charles Nydorf and Elinor Robinson
    Every Wednesday (all year round), at 7:30 PM. No fee.
    Through reading a wide range of Yiddish literature, we develop the ability to think, feel, and speak in Yiddish and make the Yiddish tradition our own.

    Jewish History Reading Group
    Athens and Jerusalem. In the centuries after Alexander the Great's conquest of the Near East, the Jews confronted Greek culture for the first time. In our readings we will consider the various ways in which Judaism responded to the cultural messages of the Greek world. The group will be moderated by Professor Tamara Green. Contact her at 212-866-3736 or Docgreen2_ny@msn.com for more information.

    Shabbat Learning & Events
    Seudah Shlishit: The Third Sabbath Meal
    Saturday, December 20 at 3:45 PM
    As the sun sinks and the shadows grow, we can stave off the weekday spirit with Seudah Shlishit, a final occasion for song and study, food and drink. The commandment of eating a third meal on Shabbat was elevated by mystics to a spiritual highpoint, a time for discussing the inner meaning of the weekly reading. If you would like to sponsor this month's seudah, please call ext 415 in the AC office.

    Special Program:What American Jews Don't know, or Don't Want to Know,about Jewish Life on the Rise in Germany"
    Friday, January 30
    With Professor Mark Cohen and others who have recently spent extended time in Berlin.

    Weekly Torah Study with Rabbi Jeremy Kalmanofsky and other AC members
    Shabbat mornings, 9:00 - 10:00 AM
    Join us to discuss the weekly Torah portion. Participants are welcome on either an occasional or regular basis.

    Learners Minyan
    Shabbat mornings 10-11 AM, 3rd floor, (not meeting 12/27)
    A perfect place to learn the Shabbat morning service in a welcoming, relaxed, intimate group. If you want to understand more about the prayers and the prayer book, the Learners Minyan is for you. You do not need to read Hebrew characters to participate in our prayers and learning. Led by rabbinical student Brent Spodek on Dec. 6 & 20,and by Rabbi Kalmanofsky on Dec. 13.

    Services
    Weekday Services
    Mondays and Thursdays 7:20 AM
    Tuesdays, Wednesdays and Fridays 7:30 AM
    Sundays and secular holidays 8:30 AM
     

    Kabbalat Shabbat Services 5:30 PM

    Shabbat Morning Torah Study 9 AM - 10 AM
    Led by Rabbi Jeremy Kalmanofsky and other Ansche Chesed members Each Shabbat we read and discuss the parashat hashavua (weekly Torah portion). Everyone is welcome to participate, whether on an occasional or regular basis.

    Shabbat Morning Services 10 AM
    Sanctuary Minyan weekly in the sanctuary
    Minyan Ma'at weekly on the 5th floor
    Beginners service weekly on the 3rd floor - not meeting on 12/27
    Minyan Rimonim 12/6 and 12/20 in the Chapel
    West Side Minyan 12/13 and 12/27 in the Chapel
     

    Children's Shabbat services
    Preschool Service, llana Garber / Shai Specht
    For families with children ages 4 and under
    11:00 a.m. - Noon. 2 South.
    Family Service, Elena Sassower
    For children ages 5-7 and their parents.
    10:45-12:15pm. 6th West.
    Family Davening, Mindy Fischer/Tommy Treitel
    For children ages 8 and up and their parents.
    11:00-12:15pm. 6 North.
     

    Family Kiddush Together
    December 13th after Children's Services- in 6W
    Families with children are invited for an extended Kiddush. This is a great time to snack, shmooze and get to know other AC families

     

    New Executive Director
    Randi Jaffe comes to us with more than 20 years experience managing, writing, and editing in not-for-profit management, much of it in Jewish organizations.

    Most recently, she managed the facility, budget, communications, computers, and endless details at the NYU Hillel house, known as the Bronfman Center for Jewish Student Life, a 6-story landmarked townhouse with 2000 users, about 100 events weekly, and multiple minyanim.

    Before joining NYU, Randi coordinated the 350-child religious school at her home congregation, Beth Elohim in Park Slope, Brooklyn, for six years. An active member of her congregation, she is currently serving in her fourth year on the Board of Trustees, serves as co-chair of the youth committee, and is chairing the first women's seder; she has also served on the ritual, early childhood, and religious school committees, organized fundraisers, co-founded the Rosh Chodesh study group, and created the first membership directory at Beth Elohim. She has also managed a 37- unit landmarked housing coop, ran publicity and publications for the Engineering School at Columbia., and has been known to write poetry from time to time.

    Randi graduated from Barnard College with an A.B. in writing and literature, and from Columbia University with an M.A. in English Literature, and studied synagogue management at Hebrew Union Collge and through membership in professional organizations. She and her husband David Roe are both native New Yorkers. They have two sons in college, and they live in Park Slope.

    Donations
    GENERAL DONATIONS
    Leonard & Joy Baxt in memory of his aunt, Malvina Miller
    Milton & Judy Birnkrant in memory of his father Harold Birnkrant and his sister, Sasha Birnkrant Alt
    Theodore & Erica Braude in memory of his father, Max Braude
    David & Amy Brauner in memory of his father, Herman Brauner
    Myriam Braunschvig in memory of her father, Jules Braunschvig
    Deborah Brodie in memory of Sue Dickman's mother, Paul Dickman, Ruth Sharfman's father, Carl Sharfman, and Deborah Rosenkranz's brother, Leon Rosenkranz; in honor of birth of Rabbi Marion & William Shulevitz's granddaughter, Josephine, Ariela Dubler & Jesse Furman's daughter, Mira Peninah Dubler-Furman, Hillary & Joe Kessler-Godin's daughter, Orli Kessler-Godin, and the engagement of Marcia Talmage to Fred Schneider
    Arline Cohen in memory of her mother, Grace S. Goldin
    Freda & Evan Eisenberg in honor of the B'nei Mitzvah of Eitan Sosner, Gabriel Paley, Avital Mintz-Morgenthau, Miriam Dreiblatt and Sasha Herscovici-Bogursky
    Paul & Mary Feinberg in honor of Dr. Jeffrey Nichols for all his many kindnesses
    Mindy Fischer in honor of the birth of Amanda & Michael Geffner's son, Joshu Aiden Geffner, Jordan Horvath & Elana Elster's daughter, Sarah Anna Elster Horvath, Amy & Jeremy Kalmanofsky's daughter, Odelya Kalmanofsky, Hillary & Joe Kessler-Godin's daughter, Orli Kessler-Godin, Marisol Ledesma & Erick DeJesus' daughter, Tristin Adriana DeJesus and the 8th birthdays of Shoshana Shapiro and Daniel Fischer Teitelbaum; in memory of Ruth Sharfman's father, Carl Sharfman
    Richard Gabel in memory of his father, Morris Gabel Phil Gold in memory of his parents, Dan & Yetta Gold
    Doris Ullendorff & Ken Gorfinkle in memory of her father, Henry Ullendorff
    Stephen Gross in memory of his brother, Jeremy Gross
    Atina Grossmann & Frank Mecklenburg in memory of her father, Hans Grossman
    Walter & Esther Hautzig in memory of his grandmother, Ernestine Hautzig
    David Kaplan in memory of his father, Max Kaplan
    Joe & Hillary Kessler-Godin in honor of the birth of Lawrence Kaufman & Melissa Crespy's daughter, Netanya Crespy Kaufman
    Franklin Klein & Susan Marlett
    Meta & Michael Levi in memory of her mother, Mary Rosenberg
    Andrew Menkes
    Shirley Pollak
    Gladys Rosen in memory of her daughter, Amanda Elizabeth Rosen
    Richard & Varda Rosenfeld in memory of Rose Reikes- Rosenfeld
    Howard Rosof in honor of the members of the Morning Minyan
    Naomi Sarna in memory of her husband, Edgar Sheller Sylvia Seidman in memory of her father, Samuel Goldstein
    Ruth Sharfman in memory of her mother, Lillian Sharfman
    Michele Siegel in memory of Ruth Sharfman's father, Carl Sharfman and Jeffrey Mayo's mother, Yetta Mayo
    Larry Silverman in memory of his father, Max Bronstein
    Frances Stiller in memory of her husband, Morton Stiller
    Ruth Sussman in memory of her father, Louis Sussman
    Hal Upbin
    Nancy Wolfson Moche in honor of Jerry Raik
    Ronnie Millman Zolin
     

    KOL NIDRE APPEAL
    Debora Difronzo & Sanda Steinbauer
    Freda & Evan Eisenberg
    Walter & Esther Hautzig
    Rebecca Joseph
    Jordan Horvath & Elana Elster
    Larry Silverman
     

    RABBI'S DISCRETIONARY FUND
    Jeff Bogursky & Marly Herscovici
    Jennifer Cowan & Dan Jacob
    Freda & Evan Eisenberg in memory of her parents, Selma & Moishe Cusher
    Eric Gertner & Nina Yahr in memory of Annette Gertner
    Fred & Jean Herschkowitz in memory of his mother, Etta Herschkowitz
    Kesher Foundation, Inc.
    Ira Krell
    Edward Krowitz & Amy Stone
     

    CHILDREN'S T'FILLAH FUND
    Stuart Fisher
    Stanley & Arlyne Zinn
     

    LIBRARY FUND
    Feygele Jacobs & Michael Cholden-Brown in memory of her father, Benjamin Janklewicz Jacobs
     

    PRAYERBOOK FUND
    Ernest & Heidi Kahn in memory of his grandfather, Sigmund Kahn, and his father, Morris Kahn
     

    KIDDUSH FUND
    Eric Gertner & Nina Yahr in memory of Annette Gertner
    Herta Shriner in honor of Sasha Bogursky's Bat Mitzvah
     

    SHELTER FUND
    Valley Restoration LDC
     

    REFUAH SCHELEMA
    Roberta Leiner By Tamara & Martin Green

    Musical Director Letter
    Letter from Rabbi Kalmanofsky on hiring a Musical Director

    For a year I have been proposing - first to the Sanctuary Minyan and now to the entire synagogue - that Ansche Chesed hire a musical professional on staff. Some people think it's a promising idea; others regard it as incompatible with Ansche Chesed's character. Let me share my thoughts on why I believe hiring the right person would be a major asset to our community. I hope you find these thoughts persuasive. In all events, everyone is invited to share your views with me and the search committee at music@AnscheChesed.org. I know you will.

    Would We Change Beyond Recognition?

    I am confident we can make a change for the better. We would be different, by evolution, not revolution.

    We should acknowledge that it would be a significant change for our community to employ a music director who would - among other things - lead services regularly. For 30 years, Ansche Chesed has built its identity partly by rejecting the very idea of designated prayer leaders. In some measure that was a healthy rejection of a certain style of Cantorial music, which often made synagogues showy and cold, and insufficiently intense for worshippers. (For comparative purposes: As post-Vatican II Catholic priests stepped behind their altars to let worshippers approach communion themselves, so post-War American Jews reclaimed a populist model that gave everyone the chance to be shaliah tzibbur, communal spokesperson in prayer.)

    I understand why some fear hiring a professional would betray that ethos. Let me assert that our core mission will always give opportunities for members of every minyan - the Sanctuary included - to lead tefilot [prayers]. That will not change. Nor would we give up on the "big tent" model of Ansche Chesed as a home for two Hebrew schools and multiple Shabbat morning minyanim. I have no desire to bring everyone to the Sanctuary every Shabbat (though I certainly hope the Sanctuary attracts more people every Shabbat!)

    Nevertheless, a music director would bring an undeniable change to Ansche Chesed. We would still provide opportunities for members to lead services, and we would still esteem their contribution. But we would also open up a new realm of experience which is not now part of Ansche Chesed's offerings: the important experience of singing with a leader who can help worshippers reach spiritual places together they could not attain by themselves. I believe this is the real meaning of "participatory" davvening - where individuals in the seats as well as individuals standing at the amud [or leader's table] are bound into a community through words and music.

    No one should be shocked that I believe clergy can enhance people's experience of Jewish life. If I believed rabbis and cantors were always disempowering, stultifying drains on a community, I would find a different job. Some 15 years ago this community elected to spend its resources to engage a rabbi. I hear no enthusiasm today for reconstituting AC today as it was two decades ago, without professional clergy. Today, all the lay prayer leaders in our various minyanim are competent. Some have more verve; some have less. Some are better at melding words and music into a total prayer experience; others are worse. And I love you all. But there are particularly talented people who can transport Jews to another plane, help them sing, and help their prayer take flight. And they can do that without turning us into a concert-audience. If we can find the right musical director, she or he can enhance our experience of worship wherever we invite him or her: the Sanctuary on Shabbat mornings, the chapel on Friday nights, morning minyan, special events, musical education for adults and kids, non- liturgical programming for the full range of our constituency.

    This would entail that we recast our self-image somewhat. But I believe Ansche Chesed would be a healthier institution as a whole, more satisfying to current members and more attractive to potential members.

    Where does the process sit?

    Our search committee has convened two public meetings, has distributed (or will soon distribute) a poll to solicit members' views. So far, about 100 people have expressed their views, either in person or by e- mail. Public opinion runs heavily in favor of hiring such a person, provided an appropriate candidate can be identified. A smaller group opposes any professional musical leadership, while another segment is not opposed in principle, but is dubious that the right person can be found. By no means have we concluded that we will definitely hire someone. We have no deadline by which the position should be filled, and we're prepared to wait for the right person. We would certainly rather add no professional than add the wrong one.

    Nonetheless, since interview season is in the winter and early spring, we have already advertised this position. It might seem premature to solicit applications for a position we are not certain to fill; but we believe we can determine whether it is possible to find the right person for this role only once we see some candidates.

    Many members are concerned about how we would pay for an additional staff member. This is a legitimate worry, but it is distinct from exploring whether we want to add such a person if we could afford it. Certainly we will not expand our staff if our budget could not bear the weight. If we decide this is a communal priority, we would probably combine other budget savings and increased, targeted fundraising to marshal the resources. The costs would depend also on yet undetermined factors, like whether the person would work full-time or part-time.

    What roles would a music director have? What kind of person should we seek?

    That is an open question. The search committee is proceeding inductively, working from the feedback of synagogue members about what they would like, and from the skills of individual candidates to shape a position that meets the maximum number of our needs. In my view, the best role for such a professional would include leading regularly on Friday night and half of most Saturday morning services in the Sanctuary, plus offering classes and musical guidance that members of every minyan could enjoy.

    The person we should seek, in my view, is informal and relaxed, with a big enough voice to make an impact in our vast Sanctuary. The person should not be a show- boat. But the person should also not be embarrassed to use musical gifts to enhance other people's experiences of prayer. This is not just lovely singing, although that is part of the job. More, the task is to give full expression through music to spiritual, deepwater prayer. I begin from the premise that a community can be built when people share such heartful song and prayer. Anyone we might hire must be able to bring us together in song. Especially in the Sanctuary, that is harder than it sounds. I have been in settings - and I bet you have too - in which a prayer leader truly leads for everyone's benefit: when he or she gathers up the rapt attention of those in the minyan, carries them along with words and music, and takes them together places they could not otherwise reach alone. There are people who can do this consistently. We should seek one.

    Why does the community need such a person? If I am not a Sanctuary Minyan, member, why should I care?

    Certainly, this proposal would have the greatest effect on the Sanctuary Minyan. But this is not a Sanctuary concern alone. First, the music director could enhance the experience of many AC members through Friday night services and other attractive programming, as noted above. Also, I believe such a person could attract members, strengthening Ansche Chesed communally and financially. Every member of AC who wants this institution to grow and attract new members should be invested in building the major portals to membership, whether or not they personally are involved in any given area. For example, that means supporting and building the Hebrew school and Havurah school, even if no one in your family attends.

    Similarly, the Sanctuary Minyan is the most likely of the Shabbat morning minyanim to welcome new members, and is the place where I, the rabbi, am usually found. Therefore every Ansche Chesed member has a stake in the Sanctuary Minyan's success. Those who do not davven there should support its growth; those who do davven there should ask what we can build which will be self-sustaining and progressive.

    Today, since all our minyanim share the same lay leadership format in prayer, it is axiomatic that people make Ansche Chesed their davvening home only if that is what they seek. But as we think about our ability to meet the spiritual needs of current and potential members, it behooves us to recognize the importance of music in prayer. Academic studies and anecdotal evidence confirm that most American Jews consistently seek a rich musical component to their worship. But no service in our building consistently offers a musically- inspired service. Each of our minyanim attains this sometimes, but none of them do so predictably, reliably, week-in and week-out. What happens when an AC member or prospective member seeks a regular, reliable strong musical element to davvening? In effect, we tell people: "We don't do that here. Why don't you try another shul."

    I recommend a different course. I recommend that we expand what Ansche Chesed offers to include a musical director who can both lead prayers and coach lay leaders for a service that regularly inspires through music. As a community we might decide that our commitment to exclusive lay-leadership in prayer is so important that it outweighs our ability to offer an alternative - the kind of prayer that leads people into spiritual waters beyond their depth. I think we would miss a great opportunity, both for our current members and our future ones, if we chose that path.

    In this vein, let me add that one productive way to think about hiring a music director is the traditional value of hiddur mitzvah, or making commandments beautiful. The traditional reading of Exodus 15.2, This is my God, and I will glorify Him, is that we should strive to do all Mitzvot in aesthetically lovely ways. Can we find a person who may make our prayer more beautiful? Yes we can.